Since accepting a teaching position at remote Fairwick College in upstate New York, Callie McFay has experienced the same disturbingly sensual dream every night. Callie’s lifelong passion is the intersection of lurid fairy tales and Gothic literature—which is why she’s found herself at Fairwick’s renowned folklore department, living in a once-stately Victorian house that, at first sight, seemed to call her name.
But Callie soon realizes that her dreams are alarmingly real. She has a demon lover—an incubus—and he will seduce her, pleasure her, and eventually suck the very life from her. Then Callie makes another startling discovery: Her incubus is not the only mythical creature in Fairwick.
When life gets crazy and migraines threaten I turn to paranormal romance. I’m not looking for a mind-blowing read, necessarily, just something to take my mind off the pain while being entertaining. The Demon Lover was more urban fantasy than romance, kind of entertaining but also full of faults.
- The story takes place in upstate New York and the author nails the ambience and setting. I’m happy to see she lives in the area – she gets it.
- At its core the book has an interesting story that may get better through the later books. The execution, though….
- The author goes for a lot of meta and it’s heavy-handed. Look, our protagonist writes about Gothic novels, then finds herself in one! Let’s point out every way the story mirrors elements found in Jane Eyre! Let’s have asides like:
Great, now I was becoming like one of the heroines of the books I wrote about, jumping at noises and imagining faces in the mist.
“I’m just pointing out that you always had the setup to turn into the heroine of one of those Gothic romances you’re always reading… and now you have.”
- The worldbuilding is haphazard and unsatisfying. Many different creatures are thrown at us and we’re not given a chance to get to know or feel comfortable with them.
- Likewise, a lot of characters are introduced quickly and in bunches. They are rather flat, often serving one key purpose and fading into the background after that. If there were a hierarchy of some sort, with minor characters staying minor, it may have been fine, but all are given equal weight, muddying the narrative.
- Callie doesn’t make many decisions, more often than not they’re made for her and she goes along. It probably fits well into the classic Gothic romance theme but it happens so often I got annoyed.
- As a professor Callie interacts with students and she gives them Sage Advice about Life ~eye roll~ that doesn’t ring true.
- The plot is segmented and broken into pieces, leaving this reader unsatisfied.
Overall Demon Lover was a disappointing read. There’s a chance things will pick up in the following books now that the world has been introduced, but I’m not sticking around to find out.