As the tomboy daughter of the town’s preacher, Billie McCaffrey has always struggled with fitting the mold of what everyone says she should be. She’d rather wear sweats, build furniture, and get into trouble with her solid group of friends: Woods, Mash, Davey, Fifty, and Janie Lee.
But when Janie Lee confesses to Billie that she’s in love with Woods, Billie’s filled with a nagging sadness as she realizes that she is also in love with Woods…and maybe with Janie Lee, too.
I like a lot about this book, so much so that it gets over my usual “enh, YA”-ness. This is no small feat, guys!
- Everything comes together well – the plot moves at a nice clip, characters and their relationships change and grow, and you end up caring about everyone, even people you don’t necessarily like.
- There’s loads of questioning rep. Billie is attracted to both a guy and a girl and she wrestles with her feelings and gender identity.
- The group of six friends is close, and guys and gals are allowed to have platonic friendships. Billie’s best friend is a guy – so rare, so appreciated.
- At the same time love is a big theme. What’s the difference between friendship love and romantic love? How about love born from a long shared history versus the fireworks of a new acquaintance?
- Perspective shifts serve the story well and don’t turn gimmick-y.
- Billie’s dad is a pastor and her circle of friends form the church’s youth group so religion comes into the story a bit. I’m agnostic and shy away from scripture in my fiction but if you’re nominally Christian I doubt you’ll bat an eye. The religious teachings aren’t pervasive, but they’re there.
- While the plot moves well once things get going they follow the track you’d expect. The contest later in the book is particularly anti-climatic, more of a checkbox so later events can come together as ordained.
- As a result the end is telegraphed and, despite some action, not as satisfying as I had hoped.
If you are a fan of contemporary YA, books that follow a group of friends, and questioning/queer representation Dress Codes for Small Towns is the book for you. I’m surprised I haven’t seen it around more – it deserves more hype.