This book languished on my to be read list for a long time, but not because I was putting it off. On the contrary, I thought about picking it up constantly but was looking for the “right” moment. A moment I needed an escape, a moment long enough to devour 189 pages in one sitting, a moment I could be quiet and sink into the world McGuire introduced in Every Heart a Doorway. Those moments lined up on an evening in late December – add a proper cup of chai and you have a near perfect escape.
The Wayward Children series is about children who fell into other worlds via some sort of portal (think Alice in Wonderland or Narnia) and, for whatever reason, eventually found their way back to the real world. This is a happy thing for some but twin sisters Jack and Jill have a… let’s call it a complicated relationship with both the realm they grew up in and and the realm they slip into.
I don’t want to give anything away so I’ll end the particulars there. I’m a fan of McGuire because she builds worlds right under your nose, no info dumps required. The narrator is not part of the story, not really, but relating it to the reader. It’s a remove that lets McGuire talk to us directly – we’re all around a campfire, hanging on her every word.
There are moments that change everything, and once things have been changed, they do not change back. The butterfly may never again become a caterpillar… [the girls] will never again be the innocent, untouched children who wandered down a stairway, who went through a door.
They have been changed.
The story changes with them.
I highlighted many passages from Doorway for this reason, but fewer in Sticks and Bones. On the whole this book is more solid and assured in its plotting and length but I still liked it a touch less than the series opener. The message – we should let kids be who they are and not impose gender or other roles upon them – is awesome, and I appreciate that there is LGBTQIA+ representation (f/f relationship), but it hasn’t stuck with me as much as I hoped.
Fear not because the next installment, Beneath the Sugar Sky, comes out in a few weeks. I’ll keep my chai close at hand, ready for that elusive perfect moment.